Known for its expansive skyline, bustling streets, and the legendary mantra ”if you can make it there, you can make it anywhere,” New York is truly the city that never sleeps. This world-famous melting pot is rich in culture, cuisine, and a unique character all its own. One moment, you’re enjoying a meal at a celebrity chef’s restaurant; the next, you’re hopping on the subway to Times Square to catch a Broadway show. With countless daily happenings, you’ll always find something to keep your calendar jam-packed.
While living amidst the bright lights and fast pace of this iconic metropolis can seem out of reach, finding an affordable apartment in New York’s Big Apple is more achievable than you think. To help you enjoy the best rental experience without breaking the bank, we’ve compiled a list of the five cheapest neighborhoods in NYC.
1. Central Harlem
-
Average 1-bedroom rent in NYC: $4,030/month
- Average 1-bedroom rent in Central Harlem: $2,354/month
- Median Home List Price in Central Harlem: $849,000
Central Harlem is a neighborhood steeped in history and culture. Situated in the northern section of Manhattan, the area is celebrated for its colorful arts and music scene, rich history, and its wide variety of culinary delights. Commuting is a breeze, with the neighborhood conveniently connected to several subway lines and trains, making it an ideal community for renters.
Things to do in Central Harlem
This neighborhood is always alive with energy and excitement. From visiting the legendary Apollo Theater to savoring a meal at Sylvia’s, the ”Queen of Soul Food,” there’s no shortage of iconic experiences. When you’re in need of a quieter escape, Central Park is just a short walk away, providing a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life.
2. Washington Heights
- Average 1-bedroom rent in NYC: $4,030/month
- Average 1-bedroom rent in Washington Heights: $2,688/month
- Median Home List Price in Washington Heights: $589,000
Washington Heights is known for its stunning views of the Hudson River and the George Washington Bridge. Here, you will find lively streets, authentic cuisine, and cultural celebrations. As you stroll along its tree-lined streets, you'll discover pre-war apartment buildings and a welcoming atmosphere that feels worlds away from the daily grind.
Things to do in Washington Heights
Explore Fort Tryon Park, a lush green space that houses The Met Cloisters, a museum dedicated to medieval art and architecture. The park also provides breathtaking views of the Hudson River and a dog run, making it a perfect retreat for you and your furkid. Round out the day with a visit to the United Palace, a historic theater that hosts concerts, film screenings, and community events.
3. Upper West Side Manhattan
- Average 1-bedroom rent in NYC: $4,030/month
- Average 1-bedroom rent in Upper West Side Manhattan: $2,708/month
- Median Home List Price in Upper West Side Manhattan: $1.49M
The Upper West Side is one of NYC’s most iconic and picturesque neighborhoods, loved by locals for its tree-lined streets, historic brownstones, and a sophisticated yet welcoming vibe. Flanked by Central Park to the east and Riverside Park to the west, this area offers a perfect balance of city living and natural beauty.
Things to do in Upper West Side Manhattan
If you love the fine arts, you must check out the Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts and explore the exhibits at the New York Historical Society. Indulge in the neighborhood's dining scene by starting the day at Barney Greengrass for its popular ”scrambled with eggs” dishes, and cap off the evening with upscale dining at The Smith, praised for its oysters and NY Strip.
4. Hamilton Heights
- Average 1-bedroom rent in NYC: $4,030/month
- Average 1-bedroom rent in Hamilton Heights: $3,320/month
- Median Home List Price in Hamilton Heights: $599,000
Known for its stunning architecture, Hamilton Heights is filled with stately brownstones, pre-war buildings, and tree-lined streets that exude a timeless appeal. The neighborhood’s elevated location provides breathtaking views of the Hudson River and the George Washington Bridge, adding to the neighborhood’s sophistication.
Things to do in Hamilton Heights
The neighborhood is named after Alexander Hamilton, one of America’s Founding Fathers, whose historic home, The Grange, is a must-visit landmark if you treasure history. Green space is readily convenient with the Denny Farrell Riverbank State Park less than a mile away. While in the park, don’t forget to swing by Sofrito where you can sip on mojitos while enjoying incredible views of the Hudson River.
5. Alphabet City
- Average 1-bedroom rent in NYC: $4,030/month
- Average 1-bedroom rent in Alphabet City: $4,001/month
- Median Home List Price in Alphabet City: $824,999
Alphabet City radiates creativity, grit, and bohemian vibes. Named after its avenues—A, B, C, and D—this area has a notable history as a hub for artists, musicians, and counterculture movements. Today, it retains its edgy, eclectic vibe while embracing community gardens, historic tenement buildings, and trendy places to rent.
Things to do in Alphabet City
Tompkins Square Park is a green oasis that serves as the neighborhood’s heart, periodically showcasing live music concerts or impromptu performances. If you’re into the late night scene, the neighborhood offers a mix of experiences—from dive bars like Mona’s, where you can shoot a game of pool, to speakeasies like Please Don’t Tell, known for its dimly-lit ambiance, craft cocktails, and its hidden entrance through a phone booth inside a neighboring business.
Make the Most of Your Move with Apartments.com
Whether you're planning a short-term stay or looking to put down roots, Apartments.com is here to help you find your perfect home in the Big Apple. With our customized search engine, you can easily explore housing options tailored to your budget and preferences. Start your journey with us today and discover the endless possibilities that await you in New York City!
*Apartment rent data provided by CoStar Group’s August 2025 reports.
